New Dogs, Old Tricks: HR Screening Is Still the Same Old Game

It’s no surprise that HR departments are using AI to screen resumes. But here’s the shocking fact: They are still using many of the same tactics that started when online Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) became popular in the early 2000s.
Yes, you read that right. HR departments have been using some form of computerized resume screening for 25 years. Back then, it was usually a combination of knockout questions on job applications and simple keyword searches. Those “ancient” tools laid the groundwork for many of the screening methods still used in modern ATS, including those powered by AI.
The technology may have changed, but the game remains remarkably similar.
Aim for a 65 to 80% Keyword Match to Get Past the Screeners
NOTE: That is a match on KEYWORDS, not QUALIFICATIONS!
This includes both smart and stupid keywords.
Smart keywords relate to the actual functions of your job, such as “consultative sales process,” “negotiations,” and “account management” for a salesperson.
Stupid keywords are the clichés we all hate, such as “excellent communication skills” and “team player.” As humans, we know these phrases don’t mean much. But automated screening tools may still be looking for them.
If HR puts these boring terms in the job description, you need to consider including them somewhere on your resume, provided they accurately describe your skills. Otherwise, you risk getting screened out simply because you lack the right keywords.
While inexperienced HR professionals may not fully understand the nuances of your qualifications, automated systems can be just as frustrating. Some screening tools recognize variations of keywords, while others are far more literal.
For example, I have seen people rejected by computer screening because the system did not recognize their degree. They held a relevant bachelor's degree, but their resume said “BS” while the system was looking for “Bachelor of Science.”
BS, indeed.
Bottom line: The ATS can be brutal, literal, and unforgiving. Worse, it can stand between you and any chance that a human will read your resume and grant you an interview.
Humans Spend Less Than 10 Seconds Reading Your Resume the First Time
HR professionals aren't spending their time poring over every detail of your resume. During that initial review, they are looking for evidence that you have the skills and experience they need.
If they can't recognize your value within those first few seconds, your resume could end up in the rejection pile.
And who can blame them? Very few people are excited about reading through a stack of resumes. Most are boring, monotonous, poorly written, or filled with fluffy phrases and outright bragging.
Which brings us to another old trick.
HR and AI Screeners Will Assume AGAINST You
As far as HR is concerned, if something isn't on your resume, it might as well not exist.
That's why you need to include information that may seem painfully obvious.
A classic example is Microsoft Office. Over the years, I have reviewed thousands of resumes. Whenever I notice that Microsoft Office isn't listed, I ask the job seeker why they left it off.
“Well,” they say, “I thought it was pretty much a given that everybody knows Microsoft Office.”
Not true, actually.
HR isn't going to give you credit for skills you haven't mentioned. If they have to make assumptions about your qualifications, education, skills, experience, or career focus, don't expect those assumptions to work in your favor.
After all, that's an easy cut for them.
HR Departments May Need to Eliminate 95% or More of Their Applicants
Here's something job seekers need to understand: The HR department is not your buddy, searching for the perfect job for you.
Their job is to CUT YOU.
When hundreds of people apply for a single position, HR must narrow that field to a manageable number of candidates. The survivors are considered the top candidates. However, that doesn't necessarily mean they are the most qualified candidates.
They may simply be the people who survived the screening process the best.
The Best Defense Against These Old Dogs
Starting with a solid base resume is one of the best things you can do for your job search.
Then, before applying for a specific position, tweak your resume to improve its keyword match. I recommend aiming for that sweet spot of 65 to 80% as a practical target, not a guaranteed passing score.
Whether you make those adjustments manually or use a dedicated resume keyword matching program like SkillSyncer.com, spending an extra 20 minutes tailoring your resume can make a huge difference.
After all, the technology may have changed, but the rules of the game haven't changed nearly as much as HR would like you to believe.
And knowing how to play that game could mean the difference between another silent rejection and your next interview.
Need help building a solid base resume? Personal Touch Career Services can help you create a resume that highlights your qualifications and gives you a stronger foundation for your job search. Schedule a free consultation
with us to get started.



Comments